A Cautionary Tale
In the fall of 2018, the once dominating retail giant, Sears, filed for Chapter 11 bankruptcy. As news of the big-box downfall spread, people began to reminisce about the days of catalog shopping. To many modern consumers, the idea of browsing a catalog, filling out a paper form, and mailing a check for payment seems almost unbelievably antiquated. Yet Sears successfully sold everything from clothes, jewelry, firearms, livestock, to even mail-order “kit homes” you could build yourself.
But as competition grew, and Sears stayed the course with the same retail model, the beloved brand, in the words of the Wall Street Journal headline, “lost the American shopper.”
Sears is a case-study-worthy tale of a brand not adapting with a changing retail landscape—and assuming that what has always worked will continue to yield the same results. However, retailers now know that the world of commerce is incredibly dynamic, and there is a sense of Darwinism’s survival of the fittest for those that won’t (or can’t) adapt.
The Need for a Unified Brand Experience
Today more retailers are seeking unified commerce—or a seamless customer experience irrespective of channel. According to Zendesk, “87% of customers think brands need to put more effort into providing a seamless experience.”
And the benefits for retailers are significant. In fact, a study done by Google found that omnichannel shoppers have a 30% higher lifetime value than those who shop using only one channel.
While brands refer to this as a “unified commerce” approach— the foundation of being able to achieve unity throughout your supply chain is built on an omnichannel mindset. But before we dig into exactly what omnichannel retail is, let’s set the context for how shopping channels have evolved over time.
History of Retail Channels
Retail began mostly as a single channel model, where consumers expected to visit a brick-and-mortar store to purchase. Eventually new channels began to emerge.
- 1845 - Mail-ordering originates with the Tiffany catalog
- 1893 – Sears, Roebuck, & Co. releases their first mail-order catalog
- 1982 – The first TV shopping network launches, Home Shopping
- 1991 – The first electronic commerce store launched, Book Stacks Unlimited
- 1994 - Money magazine published a story about the sharp rise in people "shopping from home"
- 1995 – Jeff Bezos launches Amazon.com as an online marketplace for books
- 1997 - Mobile commerce, also known as m-commerce begins via SMS texting
- 2007 - Smart-phone mobile commerce introduced
- 2010 – Omnichannel thinking introduced to the retail landscape
For example, a retailer would have “store” inventory separate from ecommerce inventory, making it complicated and cumbersome if a consumer purchased something from one channel but need to return/exchange in a different channel. Retail associates wouldn’t necessarily know how to “pick, pack, and ship” an item to consumers.
While multichannel gave consumers more options for shopping, it often led to complex retail operations, disparate systems, and complicated reporting.
Enter Omnichannel Retail
In 2010, retailers began to look for an approach that extended beyond multichannel.
Omnichannel retail (omni meaning “all”) links every retail channel together to build a seamless customer journey. Research shows that consumers are interacting with brands on a variety of channels and becoming more and more “channel agnostic.”
Simply put—consumers are looking for a unified brand experience, whether they are browsing a brick-and-mortar store, shopping on their smart phone, or buying online and picking up in the store.
The statistics for “omni-shoppers" show that they tend to spend more (both transaction size and lifetime value) and have a higher customer retention rate. So as retailers aim to target new customers, get them to engage with their brand, and keep them coming back for more—an omnichannel approach has proven an effective way to do so.
Benefits of an Omnichannel Approach
While sales and revenue can drive omnichannel strategies, there are many more benefits to a unified commerce experience:
- A customer-first approach by engaging buyers exactly where, when, and how they want to buy. They can start a purchase on one channel and complete it on another.
- More robust supply chain and fulfillment capabilities such as leveraging stores as fulfillment centers (in-store fulfillment), buy online pick up in store (BOPIS), buy online return in store (BORIS), same-day fulfillment, ship to store, and gift cards, etc.
- More protection against lost sales to competitors due to out-of-stock products or disparate inventory across your distribution network.
- Increased ability to scale your business for growth by providing a strong foundation for operational processes and your technology stack.
- Retail channel agility as the landscape morphs and changes (i.e. customer expectations, COVID-19, digital transformation, etc.)
- Increased visibility into your retail brand’s overall performance versus only siloed views per channel
How to Build an Omnichannel Retail Strategy
- Assess — Understand your current customer journey “as is.” How do your consumers like to buy? What is their path to purchase? What data and trends do you see that impact their preferences and patterns? What does a winning retail strategy look like for your brand?
- Outline priorities — What are critical must-haves for your omnichannel strategy? Why are they critical to your fulfillment plan? What departments, teams and overall functions will this impact and involve?
- Identify processes and systems throughout your supply chain that may require an omnichannel reboot:
- Product catalog – How many SKUs do you have? Do you sell kits or bundles that impact fulfillment? Do you offer personalized products that require review before manufacturing?
- Overall distribution network capabilities – How many customers can you reach, and how quickly?
- Technology touch points – How are your point of sale, ecommerce storefronts, ERPs impacted? What system, if any, gives you the overall view of sales/orders?
- Inventory – Where is it stored? Is it the same across channels? Where can you fulfill orders? Is there a view of store-level inventory? Are inventory feeds consolidated, aggregated and allocated appropriately in real-time? Do you offer preorders and backorders that impact your inventory count?
- Finance – Think about how to handle payment capture, tax, fraud, gift cards, etc.
- Return management authorization (RMA) – Who initiates? Where can buyers return products? How can you streamline your returns?
- Standardize — Unify your customer experience across all channels including return policies, promotions, etc. to prevent confusing or frustrating buyers.
- Leverage an order management system (OMS) like DeckCommerce to automate order workflows and take advantage of various fulfillment options
- Order orchestration capabilities - Enable real-time aggregation and fulfillment routing
- Enterprise-level, real-time inventory across every channel including available to sell and safety stock
- Robust transaction processing – Include advanced/delay capture, order reviews, etc.
- Aggregate view of all orders for exception management, return automation, appeasement, etc.
- Empower brand associates — Give in-store workers and online/over-the-phone customer service representative full visibility to data and orders information in real-time
- Partner with “omni-minded” partners, vendors, and systems — Find those who understand your business needs and are adapting to unified commerce requirements
- Test your order lifecycle from beginning to end – Ensure both business requirements and customer experience meet expectations for all channel combinations [(in-store fulfillment), buy online pick up in store (BOPIS), buy online return in store (BORIS), same-day fulfillment, ship to store, and gift cards, etc.]
- Measure performance and KPIs — With an omnichannel strategy, you will have visibility into the picture of your retail brand as a whole.
How Technology Empowers Omnichannel
The technology stack (or set of technology tools) behind your brand either prohibits or enables you from executing the customer experience you aim to create. For many retail brands, the "secret sauce" to creating an omnichannel customer experience is through leveraging an order management system (OMS).
Not sure if OMS is the right option for you? Here are 3 Signs Retailers Need an OMS.
An order management system effectively covers the entire lifecycle of your orders—from click to doorstep—and gives your brand fulfillment capabilities and visibility you don't have without OMS. But not all order management solutions are created equal. Understand your options for order management systems and their short and long-term benefits.
Whether you are a seasoned omnichannel connoisseur, or just now assessing how to adapt your retail strategy into a true unified experience—one thing is clear— customers are in the driver’s seat and they are on the omnichannel highway.
But heading towards a unified brand experience doesn’t mean you have to abandon your historic brand identity. Who knows what Sears could have become if they were open to adapting their business model to meet consumer preferences? Perhaps they would still be competing with other retail giants that have stood the test of time?
The CEO of Levi’s, Charles Bergh, points out that brands should “…have one foot rooted at the heritage of the past to make sure we understand where we came from, and one confident step forward in terms of driving innovation forward.”
A unified commerce experience is not only a step forward — it is a step towards where the customers already are.